Does input filter / validation code belong in the controller or the domain model?

I have been using php for awhile but am new to OO php. As an exercise for myself I am building a small MVC framework.

I realize there is probably not a definitive answer for this, but I am wondering: Where does the input filter / validation code belong?

Should it be a part of the controller, where the request is parsed?

Or is it more appropriate to have filter / validation code in the domain model, so that each domain object is responsible for validating its own info.

Any advice would be much appreciated.


Controllers would typically handle request data (GET / POST) and detect invalid form submissions, CSRF, missing fields, etc. for which the model should not be concerned about. This is the most likely place where you would write the bulk of mostly your filtering code; validation should only go as far as sanity checks for early failure (e.g. don't bother to send an email address to the model if it's not a valid email address).

Your domain objects may also provide validation hooks (even filtering), which would reduce the controller's responsibility, but in most cases I personally find it easier to work with a contract based model (the model assumes you're passing legit values) because it's easier to directly translate validation issues to specific form fields.

The model itself may do validation as well, albeit different from aforementioned input filtering (and content type validation); for instance, it might check whether an email exists in the database rather than making sure it's a valid email address.

Controller is not responsible for validation in any way, shape or form. Controller is the part which in presentation layer in presentation layer is responsible for reacting on users input. Not questioning it.

The validation is mostly the responsibility of domain objects, which are where most of domain business logic ends up withing the model layer. Some of validation is what one would call "data integrity checks" (like making sure that username is unique). Those constraints are enforced by DB structure (like with UNIQUE constraint in given example or NOT NULL in some others). When you are saving the domain object, using data mapper (or some other storage pattern), it might raise some exceptions. Those exceptions too then might be used to set an error state on a particular domain object.

If you have a form, it will be tied to one or more domain objects, which, when the form is posted, validates it. The current view then requests information from the model layer and, if there has been an error state set, displays the appropriate warnings.

Need Your Help

numpy piecewise function claiming lists are not same size

python python-2.7 numpy scipy piecewise

I'm trying to write a function to pass a variable into a piecewise function, I have:

Is it okay to have a password in a cookie or session?

php session cookies encryption passwords

I'm making a PHP CMS and I was wondering if it was okay to have, a small password encrypted in a cookie so certain users can access the admin zone who know the password. It will be encrypted, and the