What do Futures and Agents in Akka offer over Clojure's counterparts?

Having watched the presentation Composable Futures with Akka 2.0, I am curious to know what additional features the Akka implementation of Futures and Agents bring over Clojure's ones.


"Agents in Akka are inspired by agents in Clojure." This is the first line in Agent documentation on Akka and hopefully it clears the agents part of question. As far as futures are concerned, they are both same conceptually (i.e invoking an operation on a separate thread). The underlying implementation are based on java.util.concurrent, so both using same underlying infrastructure.

Scala part: The important part how the composable word come into play (both for agents and futures). If you go to akka docs you will find that you can use higher-order functions like map, filter etc. on Akka futures, i.e. a map operation on a future returns another future (and similarly for filter). This allows you to easily compose/chain together futures and wait on the final future for the final value. Now, all this is possible because the map, filter, for comprehension etc. are all based on Scala (monadic) API which basically allows any new type to provide specific implementations of these functions.

Clojure part: Now on clojure side of things, you know that map, filter etc are just normal functions that work on collections, i.e they work on something that can be traversed and hence are different concept from the Monadic API of scala. So in Clojure you will use different ways to compose futures after all Clojure (or Lisp in general) allow composability in many many ways

Need Your Help

WPF Calendar Control holding on to the Mouse

c# wpf calendar

So I dropped the standard WPF Calendar control on the MainWindow.xaml in a brand new WPF App in VS2010. If I click on a day in the calendar and then try to click the Close button for the app, I ha...

Why drag and drop not working html5?

jquery html5

I am trying to drag a file into the body of my page and pop an alert box. Why is the event not getting caught?

About UNIX Resources Network

Original, collect and organize Developers related documents, information and materials, contains jQuery, Html, CSS, MySQL, .NET, ASP.NET, SQL, objective-c, iPhone, Ruby on Rails, C, SQL Server, Ruby, Arrays, Regex, ASP.NET MVC, WPF, XML, Ajax, DataBase, and so on.