Why calloc wasn't intended to assign arbitrary values?

As per why malloc+memset slower than calloc?

malloc+memset is slower than calloc under certain conditions.

Why wasn't calloc written in such a way that it can take an extra value argument ( like memset) to override default assignment by zero? What would have been the effect of that if it were done?

Answers


These calloc or memset initializations operate on a byte level, so even memset with a value different from 0 is not that usefull. At least I don't remember having it used with different values. Mostly you allocate memory for a base type that is wider than char.

The other aspect is that calloc is initialization and not assignment. Platforms may have builtins that provide a fast initialization of all bytes to 0, you wouldn't capture this when passing an argument to initialize.

But probably the most important aspect is that this is history of C. These interfaces originate from the very beginning and are impossible to change.


That's the way it's designed.

Mainly whenever you allocate memory, you are immediately going to assign values to it. Forcing calloc to initialize a particular is going to make unnecessary overhead. For example, you want to allocate an array of 1 million int's and assign values from 1 to 1 million.

If calloc() were to take an argument like:

int *ptr;
int initValue = 3;

ptr = calloc(NumItems, sizeof(int), initValue);

then calloc() is forced to initialize initValue to all the 1 million elements needlessly.


Need Your Help

INSERT query with CASES that all share the same test statement

sql-server-2008 case insert-into

I have an INSERT INTO query and I have CASE statements that determine many of the field values. In the following however all the test statements are the same, is there any way to consolidate this?

wordpress robots

wordpress robot permalinks

my permalink was like this %postname%/

About UNIX Resources Network

Original, collect and organize Developers related documents, information and materials, contains jQuery, Html, CSS, MySQL, .NET, ASP.NET, SQL, objective-c, iPhone, Ruby on Rails, C, SQL Server, Ruby, Arrays, Regex, ASP.NET MVC, WPF, XML, Ajax, DataBase, and so on.